Interview with Paula Heisen – Portray Perceptions


I’m delighted to share this electronic mail interview with New York Metropolis-based painter Paula Heisen. My curiosity with Heisen’s artwork started upon discovering her work on Fb and was additional enriched by a go to to her Lengthy Island Metropolis studio a couple of years again.

The emotional resonance of her nature-inspired panorama and nonetheless life compositions, coupled with the richness and precision of her colour palette, left a long-lasting impression on me. Her work demonstrates distinctive spatial readability and a fragile mastery of paint utility. Heisen’s artistry transforms on a regular basis scenes into lyrical expressions that evoke the spirit of early fashionable panorama artists like Charles Burchfield.

On this dialog, Paula Heisen delves into her background, her strategy to portray, and her views on working from commentary. I’m deeply grateful for her willingness to share her time and insights for this interview.

Paula Heisen is a graduate of the Yale Faculty of Artwork MFA program. Her artwork has been featured in solo exhibitions in New York, Pennsylvania, and Texas. Heisen’s creative excellence has been acknowledged with a number of grants and awards, together with an Elizabeth Basis Grant, a New York Basis for the Arts grant, a Joan Mitchell Emergency Grant, and an Ingram Merrill Basis Grant. Moreover, she has obtained scholarships to Yale, the Skowhegan Faculty, the New York Studio Faculty, and the College of California at Santa Barbara.

Heisen’s dedication to the humanities extends to her function as an educator. She has taught at numerous prestigious establishments, together with the Style Institute of Expertise (FIT) in New York Metropolis, Lehman Faculty within the Bronx, NY, the Oxbow Summer season Program in Michigan, Yale College’s Summer season Program in New Haven, CT, and the College of California at Santa Barbara.

See extra at PaulaHeisen.com.

Arch, oil on linen, 18 x 24 inches, 2021

Larry Groff:  Are you able to recall your earliest reminiscence associated to drawing and portray? Had been there any particular experiences or influences in your adolescence that ignited your ardour for portray?

Paula Heisen:  The earliest factor I keep in mind will not be about portray or drawing, however making a snake with Play-doh. I felt the magic of making one thing out of inert materials and the way it turned alive. Highly effective sensation.

LG:  Did you could have a specific professor or mentor at Yale who made a big influence in your creative improvement?

Paula Heisen:  For undergraduate work, I went to the Faculty of Inventive Research, an impartial program inside UC Santa Barbara. This small college was for superior, self-motivated college students within the arts and sciences. Lots of the college students got here from the East Coast – they had been fast-talking and intense, which might be why I turned concerned with coming East. Numerous artists got here by means of to show a semester or give lectures. Hank Pitcher was the trainer closest to my sensibility. He painted the native panorama, which he had grown up and surfed in. I feel that his relationship to the panorama has at all times been behind my thoughts. Contemplating the state-of-the-art world within the 70s within the U.S., panorama portray was each retro and courageous. I discovered so much about how to consider colour from him – each in lessons and in seeing his work. He launched me to the work of Fairfield Porter, whose work influenced me so much. He admired Paul Georges and introduced him out to the college. I keep in mind being struck by his narrative work. Within the common artwork division, I took some drawing lessons with Howard Warshaw. I found that my concepts about drawing had been restricted – he taught me to attract and assume in three dimensions.

Ellen Portray, oil on canvas, 20 x 24 inches, circa 1974

An important trainer for me there was Keisho Okayama, who was a visitor teacher in my senior yr. He was very intense and embodied the connection between one’s emotional life and artwork. I remained associates with him after school till his loss of life in 2018. I love his work, although our pursuits differ. He noticed and painted an internalized, mystical mild, whereas I’m obsessive about how mild sculpts and defines kind.

At Yale, Natalie Charkow, Andrew Forge and William Bailey had been essential professors. I took sculpture with Charkow, and her direct approach of speaking about and critiquing artwork was each thrilling and grounded. She was one of many few ladies educating there then, and her presence was essential to the feminine college students. I used to be Andrew Forge’s educating assistant in my second yr, and that was an schooling in itself. A starting drawing class for undergraduates, each class was an mental journey and revelation. I internalized a lot about the best way he considered artwork – concerning the relationship between considering, seeing, and doing, how sophisticated and fantastic it’s. I additionally turned associates with Forge’s spouse, Ruth Miller, whereas at Yale. Her luminous presence and portray have proven me easy methods to mix a womanly spirit with deep intelligence and devotion to artwork. Invoice Bailey was sensible in a specific approach, as his work are. He had a wickedly good eye, and I discovered a lot listening to him speak me by means of a portray – whether or not it was my very own or one other pupil’s. Each Forge and Bailey revealed the magic of what portray could possibly be. Bailey at all times stated that each portray is summary. It didn’t matter whether or not you painted representationally or non-representationally, from life or your creativeness. What mattered was {that a} portray lived an impartial life – that it turned greater than a sum of its elements.

Self Portrait with Blue Shirt, 15 x 13 inches, oil on canvas, 1982

By my educating and examine, I spotted that an attention-grabbing portray has a sure stability of unity and distinction. Fashion is unimportant on this equation since that stability might be achieved in many various methods. For years, I described work that reached this stage of accomplishment as “perpetual movement machines for the thoughts.” That doesn’t precisely journey off the tongue, so I diminished it to “mechanism” or “contraption”. Studying a guide of essays, Commentary: Notation, by Andrew Forge, I got here throughout this quote in an essay about Giacometti: “The achievement of the Forties and Fifties is unthinkable with out the Surrealist expertise behind it – with out the notion, that’s, of the murals as an infernal machine.” Infernal mechanism is about proper.

LG:  How a lot did Yale’s community and status assist you in your transition from pupil to skilled artist?

Paula Heisen:  Yale was a blended bag. It did assist with grants, short-term educating gigs, and a few reveals. However I didn’t need to educate full-time. I take pleasure in it, however I discover institutional conditions troublesome to tolerate. So, I by no means used the diploma to advance myself in that route. The perfect factor about it was the intense artists who had been my fellow college students. I discovered so much from them.

LG:  Are you able to share a particular early success or breakthrough that was significantly significant to you?

Paula Heisen:  In the summertime of 1977, I went to Skowhegan, which was life-changing in some ways. It was a yr after I’d graduated from school. I spent that yr heading up the promoting graphic design part of an area newspaper. I used to be misplaced when it comes to portray – I did paint, however my efforts had no cohesion. I used to be excited to have two months to only paint with no distractions. Meals ready for us, studio offered. I shared a studio out in a cow pasture with a couple of different artists. They principally painted within the panorama, and I had this nice remoted area to myself. I wasn’t prepared for the East Coast panorama, although. The greens gave the impression to be all the identical. Coming from California, with such all kinds of greens and with hills that had been golden in the summertime, it was a little bit of a shock. I began to color night time work to keep away from the entire problem, working from sketches. I developed a physique of labor there, the primary time I’d carried out that.

Untitled, oil on paper, 16 x 17 inches, 1977

Maine Evening, 12 x 10 inches, oil on paper, 1977

Then I obtained a scholarship from Skowhegan to the NY Studio Faculty – it was the primary time I lived in New York Metropolis. That was a troublesome yr, I had no cash, no winter garments–can’t say I’d thought issues out very rigorously! I stayed for a yr in New York, went again to Los Angeles for a couple of years, then to Yale, and at last again to New York Metropolis once more. It had gotten into my blood.

Torrance Homes #3, oil on board, 9 x 12 inches, 1979

LG:  As I perceive it, for a while now, you’ve been dividing your time between being within the Catskills making panorama drawings and the still-life work you make in your studio in Lengthy Island Metropolis. Are you able to inform us slightly about the way you arrived at this workflow?

Paula Heisen:  I began to work principally from the nonetheless life once I returned to the town in 1982. Making an attempt to take care of the climate and dealing freelance jobs made panorama portray inconceivable. My first condo neglected Grand Military Plaza in Brooklyn. It confronted south, and I used the lounge as a studio. It was full of heat southern mild, which I like. I used to be additionally doing narrative determine compositions. I used to be there for 4 years and ultimately stopped doing the determine work. The curiosity was simply not there anymore. Wanting again, I feel these work had been dreadful! I would like the power that comes from one thing attention-grabbing or emotionally partaking. I met my future husband in 1985 and later moved into his apt, utilizing the additional bed room as a studio. It was so much smaller and had north mild. The work fully modified, they obtained darker and thicker and extra summary. I continued with these nonetheless lifes for a couple of years till we purchased a small home upstate within the city of Lexington, NY. For some cause, I turned enthusiastic about gardening – and I began to color the panorama once more. I take advantage of an outdated storage as my studio there, and for years, I had a graphic job that allowed me to take the summers off. Though I’d created the backyard to color from, I couldn’t take a look at it with out considering of weeds, and I returned to nonetheless life portray to flee the outside…

Montauk Membership, oil on linen, 22 x 25 inches, 1986

Round 1998, I began my very own graphic design enterprise from dwelling – which meant I now not had summers off and nonetheless life portray was once more my modus operandi. I rented a studio within the metropolis for the primary time outdoors of our condo – and have cycled by means of many areas since then. Nonetheless lifes continued to be my dominant topic in my NYC studios. I collected a number of objects and used them to create narratives. This was actually enjoyable, and I at all times despaired that I had too many concepts and never sufficient time to color. I began to
do small landscapes upstate once more in 2010. I’ve a robust feeling for this Catskill panorama – I really feel overtaken by it. I’m unsure I’ve reconciled the panorama work I do with my work in my present studio in Lengthy Island Metropolis. I really feel responsible concerning the two our bodies of labor not being related sufficient. However they each fulfill one thing important. Just lately, the nonetheless lifes have taken a flip, with solely the material remaining within the set-ups. This has opened up an thrilling new path.

Morning Glories on Trellis, oil on linen, 49 x 39 inches, 1989

Nonetheless Life with Yellow Fabric, oil on linen, 42 x 54 inches, 1989

LG:  In each your landscapes and nonetheless lives, you discover methods to restrict your views to be able to consider sure features of your motif and material. I’m curious in case you can speak about what methods you see your landscapes and nonetheless lives are going after related issues.

Paula Heisen:  I can’t say whether or not they’re going after related issues – possibly I’m too near them, however the expertise of working in every mode feels fairly completely different. For one, I often search for some sort of deep area within the landscapes. Even when I’ve a big space of darkened foliage taking over lots of area, I can escape someplace into deeper area. The nonetheless lifes have a a lot shallower area and are extra intimate. The expertise of portray them will not be as encompassing as being outdoors, the place there are numerous components to cope with – the climate, the warmth, the wind, the bugs, and many others. All these issues, even when annoying, add to the depth of portray outside and are a part of the rationale I like it. I really feel alive. I’m calmer working from the nonetheless life. I can management the sunshine higher, I don’t must take care of the climate, I can luxuriate in what I’m . The nonetheless lifes are extra introspective – and colours aside from GREEN can be utilized. There are commonalities. I at all times take into consideration atmospheric perspective – I simply use it in another way when portray from a set-up. Principally I really feel the 2 endeavors are distinct in intention and execution.

Yellow Mum and Lavender Fabric, oil on linen,
16 x 12 inches, 2018

On the Brink, oil on linen, 2007

LG:  Your landscapes appear to respect the precise qualities of a spot and are rigorously noticed however you additionally carry an expressive, lyrical simplicity that avoids being too literal. What are a very powerful features for you on this painterly strategy?

Paula Heisen:  This query type of solutions itself. I do love to attract, to seize the feeling of an object in area. However I don’t need to be slavish, to render each little factor. Some painters can do this; it is sensible with their sensibilities. I’ve developed a kind of particular person shorthand through the years. The trick is to not let it change into schematic, which I take into account a non-thinking approach of portray. I at all times need to be responding to what I see or a reminiscence of what I see. Whenever you look intently at issues, there may be a lot there; it’s at all times fascinating. Particularly timber and shrubs, I’ve by no means seen a boring form or line in a tree! Fractal progress.

Distant Inexperienced Subject, oil on board, 12 x 16 inches, 2019

LG:  Are you able to say one thing about getting simplicity from the chaos of nature?

Paula Heisen:  The simplicity comes from the preliminary emotional response to a motif. I attempt to maintain on to that all through the lengthy course of of constructing a portray, distilling it and deleting any extraneous components within the work.

White Roof, oil on linen, 18 x 24, 2023

LG:  Would you say that your landscapes mirror your interior ideas or philosophy in a roundabout way? If that’s the case please clarify.

Paula Heisen:  I’d say that as a substitute of ideas or philosophy, I’ve an emotional kinship with the areas I paint in Lexington. And with how the sunshine falls on what I’m . Yearly I really feel extra embedded within the panorama. Just lately, I watched a Swedish TV police procedural known as Jordskott, by which a aspect plot concerned the kid of the top detective. He was slowly being remodeled into plant matter. Within the final episode, he’s swallowed by the earth. I’m afraid I really feel like that at occasions! I suppose it’s a paganistic/pantheistic psychological area – all the pieces is alive.

The Inexperienced Fade, oil on linen, 14 x 18 inches, 2021

LG:  Charles Burchfield, Arthur Dove, Marsden Hartley, the Canadian Group of Seven, and equally landscape-focused early fashionable summary painters would appear to have impressed you to some extent. What portray issues would possibly you could have that these panorama painters may need additionally had?

Paula Heisen:  With regards to panorama portray, my heroes are Fairfield Porter, Marsden Hartley and Charles Burchfield. Porter for his delicate and delightful palette and for the flat shapes in his work. I checked out him so much earlier in my profession. I really feel Hartley’s ties to the panorama he cherished, and he was capable of provide you with a portray language that was easy and potent – I particularly love the later work. Burchfield is an attention-grabbing case! Typically the drawing tends towards the illustrative, however he often pulls it off along with his use of colour and lightweight. The Burchfield Penney Heart posts a portray a day on Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/burchfieldpenney/), with an excerpt from his writing. I like it. He’s a terrific author, and also you get a way of how a lot he cherished and strolling by means of the countryside.

Cut up Sky, oil on linen, 16 x 20 inches, 2023

LG:  Are you able to describe a second when a specific panorama grabbed you, and also you knew you needed to paint it? What was the emotional connection?

Paula Heisen:  Firstly of the season and all through the summer time, as the sunshine adjustments, I stroll the circuit in my Catskill neighborhood. I attempt to not impose something on what I’m , simply attempt to be receptive – virtually in a trance-like state. There’s no rhyme or cause, although I’ve a number of motifs that I return to. Normally, it occurs once I’m not considering in any respect; flip my head, and bam. It’s about having the ability to be stunned by well-known environment.

Three Timber, oil on linen, 18 x 24 inches, 2023

LG:  I used to be watching a video speak concerning the Van Gogh Cypresses exhibition on the Met. I’m curious in case you’ve seen this present and in case you would possibly share your ideas about this present. I’m significantly concerned with how Van Gogh’s expressive, stylistically swirling linear strokes for the cypresses, sky, hills, and many others. maintain up for you at the moment after years of being on tote luggage, espresso mugs, and dorm room partitions. Or does the ability of his imaginative and prescient and portray chops transcend all of the artwork world hoopla?  Can at the moment’s panorama artists portray equally nonetheless be taken critically?

Paula Heisen:  Horrible to say – I missed that present! I got here to the town for dental appointments and went proper again upstate. It has been a tough summer time, with a lot rain, and I needed to be there when the solar was out.

I really like the cypress work. I’m by no means postpone by all of the merch in relation to painters. It’s simply foolish stuff, and generally I purchase it as a joke. However a terrific portray is a good portray, and seeing it in individual is at all times an unimaginable expertise. I noticed the Munch present on the Clark Artwork Institute, Trembling Earth, final summer time. I considered van Gogh, and felt Munch had the identical intense bond with the panorama. However van Gogh was a extra exacting painter in each approach: composition, scale, drawing, colour. I’ve immense respect for him.

When it comes to “portray in an analogous method” – I don’t assume something is off-limits when it comes to inspiration. That’s one beauty of the loopy time we live in proper now. Persons are free to observe what pursuits them. It doesn’t matter what somebody paints, but it surely has to have an emotional core.

 

The Magic Hour, oil on linen, 16 x 20 inches, 2023

LG:  In a few of your panorama drawings, the ingenious methods of organizing the tones and marks remind me slightly of Van Gogh’s later drawings. Do you take into account your drawing research or stand-alone drawings for their very own sake? What are you able to inform us about the way you go about drawing the panorama?

Paula Heisen:  I discussed my motif looking earlier…I {photograph} the issues I’m struck by, and manage the pictures by time of day and climate. I allow them to sit. Normally, there are a couple of that I do know I need to do, and I’ll take a look at the photographs to see if I’m proper. That’s step one. The drawings are a technique to manage my ideas. I consider them as research, however they’re satisfying as stand-alone items. I’ve began sitting on a stool as a result of that will get me to the sight-line I’ll have once I stand to color. I sketch first in pencil after which begin with an almost spent Pigma Graphic pen and transfer on to a more recent, darker pen. I’ve lots of these pens, they usually solely final one or two drawings earlier than they get too darkish or run out of ink. I used to do these painstaking ink washes. I layered mild washes, steadily shifting to the darks as I labored. I cherished doing them, very calming. I did lots of them the yr after 9/11 – useful when it comes to my psychological well being. I consider the pen drawings in the identical approach, going from mild to darkish, little by little.

The Magic Hour, Pigma Graphic pen on paper, 7 x 9 inches, 2023

Tangle, Pigma Graphic pen on Strathmore paper, 8.75 x 7 inches, 2022


LG:  You usually have views of back-lit scenes, and the play of sunshine and shadow takes on nice significance. Daylight adjustments in a short time, and coping with such a posh topic with the clock ticking is kind of the problem. Please inform us one thing about the way you go about capturing the texture of pure mild together with your colour decisions and compositional choices.

Paula Heisen:  Lots of my photographs are backlit – that’s when the character of the tree or shrub pops out like a star on a stage, with their arms out, belting a tune.

When it comes to the altering mild – usually, the second I’m concerned with doesn’t final very lengthy. It stays in my thoughts, however you should glide. I often paint for about 3 hours, and issues change so much in that point. I discover that I like the best way the solar hits completely different elements of a motif at completely different occasions, so each portray is a set of moments. No matter is sensible with the portray.

 

Barn, Early Morning, oil on linen, 14 x 18 inches, 2020

Colour – it’s a sophisticated topic! One of the simplest ways to explain how I give it some thought is the Munsell Colour Stable, which is a kind of three-d colour wheel, with colours shifting from darkish to mild vertically and hues organized across the central backbone that transfer from desaturation to full saturation horizontally. It’s the idea of this that pursuits me, not his explicit pigments. I’ve a easy double-primary palette, with heat and funky variations of every major. I additionally use cadmium inexperienced as a result of it does one thing no blended inexperienced might do. I not often use it straight, but it surely’s helpful. Black, yellow ochre, white. I’m at all times serious about the place a specific colour could be relating to worth and hue on my internalized Colour Stable. This palette is flexible sufficient to get me no matter I need or want.

LG:  Do you determine in your essential colour scheme or concord and blend accordingly earlier than portray or combine your colours because the portray progresses?

Paula Heisen:  I do small colour research for every portray, that are the identical measurement because the drawings, about 7 x 9 inches. Then, I combine the palette from the colour examine. Normally, it takes a couple of hours to do this. I may also have a sketch on the canvas earlier than I am going out to color with the complete palette. This helps me to calm down, for the reason that altering mild and all the opposite distracting issues about panorama portray are crazy-making. I need to have enjoyable on the market and be happy with the mark-making. Having the colour labored out helps with that. After all, lots of improvisation nonetheless goes on.

colour examine for Three Timber, oil on gessoed paper, 7 x 8.75 inches, 2023

colour examine for Darkish, oil on gessoed paper, 8.75 x 7 inches, 2023


LG:  How do you see shadows as greater than only a visible instrument, however as a story or symbolic component inside your nonetheless lives? Are you able to describe a particular piece the place shadows performed an important function within the total composition and which means?

Paula Heisen:  Shadows are actually essential to me! I watched countless movie noir motion pictures once I was a child. I cherished them. Black and white, easy shapes – deep area and foreground in dialog. You’re ready to take action a lot with that!

A number of my nonetheless lifes in the previous few years have shadows bigger than the lit objects, and I consciously desire a sense of one thing looming. In Darkness Above, this was the distinguished approach I believed concerning the setup. It was after a yr and a half of Covid, and I felt all of the disorientation and concern of that point. A couple of years in the past, I titled a portray Doppelganger. That conveys the metaphorical sense I’ve about shadows: they’re ghosts, twins, recollections, traces… After all, the place there’s a shadow, there may be superb mild, gilding objects with gold or moonshine.

Darkness Above, oil on linen, 26 x 20 inches, 2022

LG:  In your strategy to still-life portray, you’ve eloquently said in your Zeuxis interview “Conversations with Paula Heisen, Sydney Licht and Rachel Youens”, limiting your setups to just some components, akin to a flower, patterned material, and shadows, you paradoxically broaden what you are able to do. This notion of simplicity resulting in complexity is each intriguing and counterintuitive. Might you elaborate on this philosophy and clarify how this strategy informs your inventive course of? Should you can, possibly you possibly can level to a particular instance.

Paula Heisen:  The development of my nonetheless life imagery is unusual even to me. Initially I used to be excited with the thought of the objects infused with some narrative, both a private one, or one based mostly on world occasions. Usually, a change of place has induced a change in imagery, and once I moved to my studio in Lengthy Island Metropolis from Brooklyn, I misplaced curiosity within the narratives. I struggled for a few yr earlier than concentrating on the patterned materials and flowers – an countless supply of thrilling concepts. As with movie noir, I’ve a childhood love of materials. After I was 5, I hypnotized myself by trying on the ladies’s attire within the pews in entrance of me to alleviate the boredom of Mass. This was within the 50s, and there have been lots of colourful patterns. I discovered to stitch once I was older, and the material aisles had been heaven. I needed items of all of them! After I began utilizing cloth extra in my nonetheless lifes, I relived that have. Ultimately, I moved away from the tabletop as a construction for the work. It could appear that simply having cloth and flower is reductive, but it surely opened up the area in an attention-grabbing approach. There’s an openness and a floating sensation that I’m shifting towards now. It appears extra associated to the landscapes.

Astroemeria and Shadow, oil on linen, 18 x 14 inches, 2020

Barn and Mountain, oil on linen, 16 x 20 inches, 2023


LG:  Our artwork world at the moment is full of a cacophony of kinds, mindsets, and an ever-growing emphasis on digital and conceptual mediums; conventional observational portray can generally appear overshadowed and even anachronistic. I like to listen to about how different painters cope and navigate this terrain that usually might care much less about custom and superbly made work. Will conventional portray ever lastly keep placed on its ‘deathbed’ or do you imagine that it holds a singular and irreplaceable worth that continues to resonate with audiences at the moment?

Paula Heisen:  Like intercourse, I feel portray will at all times be round! We’d like it. Is one thing useless when folks need to do it? When there’s a neighborhood of like-minded artists who share the identical pursuits and obsessions?

In 2019, we went to 2 caves in France with prehistoric work: Peche Merle and Niaux. It was awe-inspiring – the ability and the power of the drawings are nonetheless very important at the moment. Seeing that, who wouldn’t need to do one thing prefer it?!

There’s a freedom at the moment that I alluded to earlier. Folks can do something, assume something, with regards to “artwork.” I don’t begrudge anybody no matter route they take, despite the fact that I may not be personally . I like being intently related to the wealthy custom and historical past of Western portray and having fun with the intelligence of artists working in several occasions and locations.

Loopy Timber, oil on linen, 18 x 24 inches, 2022

LG:  Are you able to speak about your experiences navigating the dichotomy between making good work and the calls for of selling your work? How do you keep targeted in your creative imaginative and prescient and keep your ardour for portray amidst the complexities of the New York Metropolis artwork market? Has this dynamic influenced or modified your strategy to your work in any approach?

Paula Heisen:  I discovered it almost inconceivable to complete this interview whereas portray this summer time. It interfered with my absorption within the panorama. That’s the issue with utilizing language for a non-verbal exercise – it takes you away from the essence of the work, as your query implies. I’m positive all of us really feel that. Talking of doppelgangers, proper now, I’m studying Doppelganger by Naomi Klein (not Naomi Wolf!) A serious theme is how the presentation of the self on, say, social media creates a ghost self. And the way that ghost self takes on its power and trajectory. I’ve been fairly lively on Fb and Instagram and have actually felt that occuring. However when you could have a present, you should let that satan within the room. You go into salesperson mode and face the attendant vulnerabilities and indignities. Maybe as a result of I’m older, it doesn’t have an effect on me as a lot because it used to. We’re sure by the conventions accessible to us and must navigate between their calls for and our deepest wants.

Subject of Inexperienced, oil on board, 14 x 11 inches, 2017



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *